Skip to content
⌕ ♡ Cart0 Shop Cookies →

Custom Cookie Gift Box · Step into the Bakery

Build a box that tastes like you remembered them.

Choose a size, mix the 24 chef-developed flavors, slip in a handwritten note, and we'll bake your box within 48 hours of leaving the oven — never frozen, always bakery-fresh.

Start Building See Gifting Options

Craft promise — every flavor ships in minimums of two cookies, so each batch gets the small-batch attention that makes it worth gifting.

  1. 01 Pick a Size
  2. 02 Choose Flavors
  3. 03 Wrap & Note
  4. 04 Review & Ship
Open kraft gift box filled with twelve assorted gourmet cookies on a marble slab
As featured on Food Network Best Thing I Ever Ate · 2023

The Builder · In Four Beats

A four-step path from craving to doorstep.

No hidden fees, no surprise minimums — just a clear walk from your first tap to the moment the box lands on their counter. Every step is reversible until you confirm at checkout.

  1. 01

    Pick a Size

    Choose a 6-, 12-, or 24-cookie box. Larger boxes unlock better per-cookie pricing — our most-gifted format is the 12-cookie mixed box.

    From $28
  2. 02

    Choose Flavors

    Mix any combination from 24 chef-developed flavors. Minimum 2 cookies per flavor — our small-batch craft promise so every cookie gets the attention it deserves.

    Min. 2 per flavor
  3. 03

    Wrap & Note

    Add a kraft gift sleeve, satin ribbon, or our handwritten-on-cotton-paper note. Optional corporate-branded sleeves for B2B orders of 10+ boxes.

    From $4 per add-on
  4. 04

    Review & Ship

    Confirm the lineup, choose a delivery window, and we bake within 48 hours of shipping. Carbon-neutral delivery included on orders over $35.

    Ships in 48 hours

The 24-Flavor Catalog

The hardest part is choosing.

Eight hero flavors below — taste them through the eye before you taste them through the box. The full 24-flavor roster unlocks inside the builder, including six limited-edition seasonal drops.

Browse All 24 →
Sea Salt Brownie cookie on a linen napkin
Chocolate Decadence

Sea Salt Brownie

Fudgy dark-chocolate interior, crackled top, finished with hand-flaked Maldon.

Brown butter toffee cookie on kraft paper
Brown Butter Classics

Brown Butter Toffee

Nutty browned-butter base, pockets of house-made toffee, soft-centered.

Toasted honey lavender cookie on a ceramic plate
Floral & Herbal

Toasted Honey Lavender

Wildflower honey, culinary lavender, a quiet finish that lingers.

Dark chocolate chunk cookie on a marble slab
Brown Butter Classics

Dark Chocolate Chunk

72% Valrhona chunks, browned butter, a whisper of espresso.

Pistachio rose cookie on a brass plate
Floral & Herbal

Pistachio & Rose

Sicilian pistachios, dried rose, a tender crumb that snaps cleanly.

Brown butter snickerdoodle on a wooden board
Brown Butter Classics

Brown Butter Snickerdoodle

Cinnamon-sugar crust, chewy center, our most-requested remix.

Miso caramel cookie on a ceramic plate
Chocolate Decadence

Miso Caramel

White miso, slow-cooked caramel, a savory-sweet edge that surprises.

Spiced maple pecan cookie on parchment
Seasonal Limited · Fall '24

Spiced Maple Pecan

Vermont maple, toasted pecans, warm spice — back through December.

The Moment a Box Becomes a Gift

Layer the details that turn cookies into a memory.

Four small touches — handwritten note, ribbon-tied wrap, branded sleeve, or a 25-cookie team box — lift the moment from delicious to remembered. Most gift orders add at least two.

Handwritten note on cotton paper tucked inside a kraft gift box
Most-Loved Add-On

Handwritten Note, Real Pen

Type your message at checkout — our Brooklyn team handwrites each note on cotton-fiber paper in brown ink. 240 characters, no extra charge.

Kraft gift box tied with a sage-green satin ribbon
+$4

Ribbon-Tied Wrap

A finished bow in sage, rust, or cream — ready to hand over without rewrapping.

Stack of branded kraft cookie sleeves on a marble slab
Corporate · 10+ Boxes

Branded Sleeves

Add your logo to the kraft sleeve — used by 380+ corporate clients including Spotify and Glossier.

Large team cookie box filled with an assortment on a wooden board
B2B · From 14 Boxes

Build Your Team Box

A 25-cookie corporate format with a custom belly band, drop-shipped to up to 50 addresses per order. Average B2B order is 14 boxes.

Explore Corporate Gifting →

The Freshness Promise

Baked within 48 hours of leaving our Brooklyn kitchen. Never frozen. Never thawed.

Every box you build leaves the oven at our 600-sq-ft Brooklyn kitchen and arrives at its destination within 48 hours. We ship to 47 U.S. states with a 98.6% on-time delivery rate over the last 12 months — and we back every box with a 100% freshness guarantee.

  • Brown-butter base — every flavor starts with butter cooked until it smells like toasted hazelnut.
  • 48-hour bake-to-ship — no flash-freezing, no vacuum-sealing, no shortcuts.
  • Carbon-neutral delivery — free on 92% of orders via our partners Cloverly and Route.
  • Freshness guaranteed — if a box doesn't arrive bakery-fresh, we replace it.
Start Building Your Box
Baker pulling a tray of golden brown butter cookies from a warm oven

Why Builders Trust Us

  • 4.9/5 Trustpilot rating · 14,832 verified reviews
  • 3.2M+ Cookies baked and shipped since 2019
  • 380+ Corporate clients gifting with us
  • 2024 SOFI Gold · Best New Dessert · Specialty Food Association

As seen in Bon Appétit, The Today Show, O Magazine, and Food Network. 1% of every order is donated to City Harvest — $187,400 contributed since 2020.