Best Seller
Brown Butter Bite
Our flagship cookie — nutty browned butter, flaky sea salt, a chewy-crisp edge.
$25.00
Add to Cart
The Cookie Catalog · Est. 2019, Brooklyn
Buy Gourmet Cookies Online, Baked in Brooklyn & Shipped Bakery-Fresh.
Twenty-four chef-developed flavors — from Sea Salt Brownie to Toasted Honey Lavender — small-batch, brown-butter, and on their way to your door within forty-eight hours of leaving the oven. Never frozen. Always hand-finished.
- Free carbon-neutral shipping on orders over $35
- 100% freshness guarantee
- Ships to 47 U.S. states
As featured on
Food Network
"Best Thing I Ever Ate" — 2023
Shop by moment
The Working Grid
All 24 Flavors, Shipped Fresh from Our Brooklyn Kitchen.
Filter by flavor family, dietary note, occasion or price — every box leaves the bakery within twenty-four hours and arrives within forty-eight. Single-flavor 6-packs, variety 12-packs, and pre-curated gift boxes are all available below.
Best Seller
New
Sea Salt Brownie
Fudgy dark chocolate, a crackled top, finished with hand-flaked Maldon salt.
$26.00
Add to Cart
Seasonal
Toasted Honey Lavender
Wildflower honey, toasted oats and a whisper of culinary lavender.
$27.00
Add to Cart
Gift-Ready
The Variety Pack
Two of each: Brown Butter Bite, Sea Salt Brownie, Toffee Crunch, Vanilla Bean.
$49.00
Add to Cart
Gift-Ready
The Brooklyn Gift Box
Eighteen cookies, six flavors, hand-tied ribbon — the one we send to ourselves.
$69.00
Add to Cart
Toffee Crunch
Brown-butter dough loaded with house-cracked toffee and a hint of espresso.
$27.00
Add to Cart
Vanilla Bean Classic
Madagascar vanilla bean, brown butter, a soft center, a crisp edge — the quiet one.
$25.00
Add to Cart
B2B
Corporate Gifting Box
Custom-branded ribbon, handwritten cards, 12 or 18 cookies — used by 380+ companies.
From $70.00
Start a Quote
Showing 8 of 24 flavors
Load 16 more flavors
Subscribe & Save
Never Run Out of the Good Stuff.
Pick a flavor lineup, choose a cadence — every shipment is baked within twenty-four hours of leaving the oven and arrives bakery-fresh at your door. Ten percent off every box, free carbon-neutral shipping, and a rotating seasonal drop in every fourth delivery.
- 10% off every shipment
- Free shipping on every order
- Flavor rotation — seasonal drops included
- Skip or cancel anytime, no commitment
Average subscription: 12 cookies per box · billed monthly · managed from your account
The Cookie America Is Sending.
A small Brooklyn kitchen, three point two million cookies later — here's what's stacked up in our favor.
Trustpilot Rating
Across 14,832 verified customer reviews — the #1 ranked U.S. cookie brand of 2024.
Cookies Shipped
Baked and shipped nationwide since the Brooklyn kitchen opened in 2019 — and counting.
Corporate Clients
Including Spotify, Goldman Sachs and Glossier — averaging 14 gift boxes per B2B order.
SOFI Gold Award
Specialty Food Association — Best New Dessert, awarded to the Brown Butter Bite line.